they say dry your tears and face life joyfully and how am i supposed to obey? it is not that simple, i am a coward and i am lost. my face is raining and umbrellas are foreign. the instruction manual is written in a language i do not understand. the snow is spinning around me and my hands are frozen, my fingers are falling off, can’t you see it? can’t you see me? the sun does not know me. the sun burns my retinas. my lungs are full of blood and i can finally breathe. don’t you know? don’t you hear it? i pick a rose and it does not scratch me. there are no rosebushes here. i’ve been laying in the road for a decade. this week was the longest day of my life. the clock is a liar. the calendar leers at me. was i ever a child? tomorrow was years ago. yesterday will happen centuries from now. aren’t you looking? aren’t you feeling it? life lifts my face with its finger and i fail to meet its eyes. the rain persists. i am screaming.
do you hear me?

*some of the stylistic choices i made in the poem are not compatible with the edublogs editor
This poem is in response to the short story Half A Day by Naguib Mahfouz, specifically the quote “Dry your tears and face life joyfully”. In the beginning of the story, the narrator and main character has mixed feelings about going to school. He is essentially told to be a man and suck it up, which is something a lot of boys and men have to deal with when their mental health isn’t great. While the story itself is not about mental health, it expresses the whirlwind of emotions, thoughts, and beliefs one goes through as their life progresses. Especially as children, many of us are taught to “switch off” our emotions- women are expected to be docile and quiet, and anger is seen as a sign that she is too wild and crazy. Meanwhile, men are supposed to be cool and calm, without complaining or being sad, as it is a sign of weakness. This suppression carries into the teenage years and often into adulthood, when mental health problems begin to arise and one cries out for help without ever really being heard. It has been proven that bottling up one’s feelings can often lead to mental, emotional, and even physical long-term effects that only make everything worse.

Throughout the short story on which this poem is based, there are several contradictions and changes- such as the narrator at first finding school nerve-wracking, then cherishing it and finding it enjoyable, then once again hating the monotony and arduous environment. This can also be seen as the teacher being kind and sweet but then also stern and resorting to physical discipline. Another example of these contradictions is when the narrator leaves school and meets a familiar man, who says he is not doing too well, but then praises God anyways. These juxtaposed contradictions serve to prove how life is chaotic and unpredictable, the biggest example of entropy. These disorderly qualities were emulated in my poem, where I make several direct contradictions, such as “the sun does not know me. the sun burns my retinas” and “my lungs are full of blood and i can finally breathe”. These lines are tied to the prompt, “Dry your tears and face life joyfully”, as it is not possible to be joyful when life is full of confusion and contradiction. I personally find that there’s a lot of things I cannot comprehend because they are not logical, even though they are just facts of life. It can be hard to accept these truths and dry one’s tears when one is surrounded by the unpredictability of existence.
Another quality of the story that I emulated in my poem is the element of questioning, and the internal monologue in general. Once the narrator of Half A Day leaves the school, he is surprised by all the changes that have taken place while he was at school, questioning where the gardens and fields of his childhood have gone. In my poem, these questions are more direct, asking the reader if they can hear them, see them, feel this confusion. A stylistic choice I made in this poem was to bold the questions more each time, indicating intensity and urgency. While the story’s mood was one of bewilderment and disorientation, the poem is more of desperation, anxiety, and angst. Questioning is a way to indicate the importance of a detail, such as the industrialization and modernization in the short story, or the warped sense of time in the poem. Tying these details into the prompt, it is apparent that it is not as simple as drying one’s tears and moving on from past trials and tribulations. There are always inconsistencies and things to question, which makes facing life with joy much more difficult and complicated than it sounds.
There are also specific elements of the story that I incorporated into the poem, such as the rapid and jumbled passage of time, as well as childhood’s fleeting pace. The repetition of the questions and individual statements further the urgency and confusion that is meant to be presented in the poem. The true response to the prompt is present in the final line, “life lifts my face with its finger and i failed to meet its eye”. It adds an element of personification to the prompt- the speaker of the poem is unable to face life, with joy or otherwise. The line “tomorrow was years ago. yesterday will happen centuries from now” also alludes to the part in the story when the whole man’s life passes by in half a day- again, the warped sense of time. In the beginning of the poem, it states “my face is raining” and in the end, this motif is again brought up by “the rain persists”. This cycling back to the beginning is similar in the story, as the narrator keeps talking about how his father will pick him up from school, but instead, it is the grandson who takes him home.


Dear Eda,
Reading your personal response to your prompt, I was quite impressed with how detailed you were in your reasonings and thinking. At first, as I was reading your poem, beautifully written might I add, I was unable to reach a conclusion as to what you were getting at, but when I read your following paragraphs on your explanations I was able to understand you a lot more. I also liked how you added bits of personal experiences and feelings into the poem itself. An example: “I personally find that there’s a lot of things I cannot comprehend because they are not logical, even though they are just facts of life”. I liked this particular sentence because as we grow up and find our own personal beliefs and reasoning, things can seem confusing and disorderly.
One thing I suggest for your next post is to link your ideas universally. As the reader, I got a lot of connections to the short story and to your personal thinking but I did not really get lots of universal concepts. This is just something little that I noticed, however, it did not affect the quality of your writing
Overall, it looked like you put a lot of time and effort into this blog, that is something I as the reader appreciate. Good work and can’t wait to see your future writings!
Sincerely,
Annabel
Dear Annabel,
Thank you for reading and responding to my post! Your feedback is very flattering. After looking over my piece again, I definitely did notice the lack of connections from my concepts to society, and will definitely remember to include those next time- your advice is very helpful. Thank you so much!!
Hello Eda,
I really liked your personal response to “Half a Day.” You did a very well connection between your ideas and the short story. I really liked how you used the idea of contradictions. We make a lot of contradictions, whether we know it or not, and it makes our life more complicated. It gets me thinking about how contradictions can shape our life to be more complicated and it has greater affect on us.
I would suggest adding a personal experience of yours or a real world example, just so the reader can find if they can find a experience relatable. Maybe ever get them thinking about points you brought up and find connections to their life.
Overall, I think your blog is very good and has polish. Keep up the good work!
Thank you,
Aleksey
Hi Aleksey,
Thank you so much for your feedback! I appreciate it. For next time, I will make sure to make connections from my points to myself- perhaps a personal experience would have helped my statements be more relatable to the audience. Thanks again!
Sincerely,
Eda
Dear Eda,
I am speechless. Both your poem and your explanation of the poem are stunningly written. Your choices for vocabulary are precise, without being artificial, and encapsulate the exact meaning that you wanted your paragraphs to convey. I really enjoyed how you played around with the contradictions of the story and how it not only was a response but a completely new idea built up from the themes and motifs of the inspiration. I liked how instead of looking at the short story as a whole, you focused in on a singular idea, creating something entirely new in the process.
As others have previously stated, the thing I think that you could improve on is tieing your explanations in with the real world. that would further show the significance of what you are discussing and will create a unifying tie-in with the audience.
I genuinely loved this post and I hope that you keep up the amazing writing!
-Rowan